BMC Health Services Research Политика здравоохранения
Dependent autonomy: developing and refining a theoretical construct of managerial autonomy in healthcare
Аннотация
Abstract Introduction Value-based healthcare (VBHC) and High-Value Health System (HVHS) frameworks identify components intended to support healthcare transformation. Their practical use may depend partly on organisational conditions affecting managerial authority. This study aimed to develop and refine dependent autonomy as a proposed theoretical construct concerning the practical exercise of delegated authority. Methods A sequential two-stage design was used. Stage 1 involved secondary qualitative coding of published findings from four empirical programme studies, using directed content analysis informed by Decision Space Theory and organisational theory. An earlier scoping review served as a sensitising source. Stage 2 combined an external scoping review across three databases with hybrid deductive–inductive framework synthesis. Study selection and analytical interpretations underwent independent review in Stage 2. No formal critical appraisal was undertaken. Results Stage 1 generated three themes: enabled yet contingent autonomy , organisational capacity as a conditioning force , and coordination as integrative yet complexity-generating . Stage 2 included 78 articles and yielded 482 analytical evidence statements. External findings informed refinements concerning deployable capacity, recognised managerial legitimacy and variation across functions, contexts and time. The synthesis proposed dependent autonomy as the organisationally conditioned actionability of formally delegated managerial authority. Four propositions concerned formal authority, organisational conditions, conditional consequences, and feedback and reconfiguration. Conclusions Dependent autonomy may help examine how organisational arrangements enable or constrain managerial action, including in VBHC/HVHS implementation. The proposed framework distinguishes managers’ practical scope for action from improved organisational performance. Its explanatory value and proposed relationships require empirical examination; effects on patient value were not established.