Oikos Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
Resource competition, herbivory, and the consequences of interacting with a protection mutualist for coexistence of two plant species
Abstract
A protection mutualist can mediate the coexistence of two plant species that simultaneously compete for a soil resource and are fed upon by a shared herbivore. The protection mutualist can increase the fitness of its interaction partner by deterring herbivore feeding, killing the herbivore and so decreasing herbivore abundances, but may also directly impose other costs on its partner. This paper develops and analyzes a model of this four‐species community module in which two plant species that compete for a single limiting resource and are both fed upon by an herbivore, and one plant species produces nectar to attract the protection mutualist that both deters herbivore feeding on the attracting plant and kills the herbivore. If the protected plant is the better resource competitor, the actions of the protection mutualist generally increases its demographic advantages that then drives the other plant extinct. In contrast, if the protected plant is the poorer competitor, the protection mutualist can facilitate coexistence of the plants if the cost of attracting the mutualist is not too significant and the mutualist does not impose too much mortality on the herbivore. Also, the actions of the protection mutualist may indirectly benefit the unprotected plant enough to drive the protected plant extinct.