Phylogenomic evidence for extensive horizontal transfer of anaerobic benzoyl-CoA reductase operons across bacterial phyla

Tan, Boonfei, Zafra, Christian, Ng, Charmaine
BMC Genomics · Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI: 10.1186/s12864-026-13569-y

Аннотация

Background Anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds, which are major pollutants in sediments, aquifers, and contaminated subsurface environments, proceeds through a central dearomatization step catalyzed by benzoyl-CoA reductases. Two mechanistically distinct classes exist: the ATP-dependent Class I BCR and the ATP-independent Class II BAM. Although horizontal gene transfer (HGT) has been proposed to shape their distribution, a genome-scale phylogenomic assessment has been lacking. Methods We screened GTDB r232 genomes by gene-specific homology filtering with cross-reactivity resolution, every reference sequence verified against its NCBI record. Five complementary phylogenetic tests, DTL reconciliation, AU topology tests, gene concordance factors, Mantel tests and Robinson-Foulds comparisons against a length-matched control, quantified discordance. Substrate repertoire was assessed by screening 12 anaerobic upper pathways with enzyme-family-specific identity thresholds and decoy references. Results At a 40% identity threshold for bcl and bamB we identified 959 pathway-complete genomes, 955 bacteria across 16 phyla and four archaea; the total ranges from 581 to 2,034 across thresholds of 50% to 25%. Class II systems occur in 21–33% at thresholds from 25% to 50%; Desulfobacterota and Bacillota are almost entirely Class II. All five tests indicate discordance, Robinson-Foulds distances exceeding a length-matched control by + 0.056 for Class I ( p = 1.5 × 10⁻⁴) and + 0.275 for Class II ( p = 1.1 × 10⁻¹⁴), and reconciliation infers 1.5–1.7 times more transfers than a vertical-inheritance control. Class I operons duplicate rarely and need fewer taxonomic transitions per tip; Class II operons duplicate more often and sit among iron-sulfur and flavin electron-transfer proteins. Matched on gene number, compactness is comparable: 88.0% against 83.0% carry four subunits within one 50 kb window. Substrate associations differ by class but are not separable from host lineage. Conclusions Predicted genomic potential for anaerobic benzoyl-CoA metabolism is more widespread than recognized, and the ATP-independent Class II system is more common than Class I-based surveys will detect. Subunit phylogenies are more discordant than vertical inheritance predicts, and the classes differ: Class I subunits remain relatively congruent with the organismal phylogeny; Class II subunits have partly independent histories. Taxon-specific surveys may therefore underestimate community-level aromatic degradation potential in anoxic environments.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи