Asia Pacific Education Review Education
Preservice teachers’ professional judgement in GenAI-supported lesson planning
Abstract
Lesson planning asks preservice teachers to consider how lesson aims, activities, and assessment fit together. Generative AI (GenAI) can now offer a complete draft in which many of these choices have already been made. Studies have examined the quality of generated plans and how preservice teachers prompt, evaluate, and revise them. Yet less is known about the educational rationale behind specific choices in a generated plan. This qualitative study explores how professional judgement becomes visible when preservice teachers use GenAI to plan lessons. We analysed interviews with six preservice teachers in China alongside the planning materials they provided. Participants considered curriculum requirements, classroom feasibility, anticipated teaching, and anticipated student responses when judging GenAI suggestions. Their reasons varied across planning episodes and within individual plans. At times, they examined an example or activity closely while offering little explanation for a lesson structure they had retained. These accounts suggest that an apparently complete plan may draw attention to some decisions while leaving others less closely examined. The findings point to the value of keeping lesson aims, sequence, learner activity, and assessment open to professional judgement during teacher preparation.