International Journal of Ethics Education Political Science and International Relations
Professional ethics without morality: Rethinking “ethics across the curriculum”
Abstract
The “standard approach” to professional ethics in higher education can be expressed by the following syllogism: (1) Distinguishing moral right from wrong is properly the task of normative ethics; (2) Professional ethics requires distinguishing moral right from wrong inside professional practice; (C) Therefore, professional ethics is properly an extension of normative ethics to professional practice. This essay argues that we have long had reason to acknowledge the falsity of (2). The norms and standards governing professional practice are derived from the structure and function of professional organizations. Abiding by those norms is a matter of awareness of industry best practices and instrumental means-end reasoning. It does not require general moral judgment in either a personal or professional capacity. Recognizing this has significant consequences for how we think about teaching ethics across the curriculum, most notably for how we structure the academic division of labor in professional ethics instruction.