Privileged yet precarious postdoctoral becoming: A new materialist duo-ethnography of Chinese PhD returnees
Abstract
Scholarly interest in the return migration of internationally trained academics has grown considerably, particularly in countries such as China that actively recruit overseas talent. Existing studies have largely focused on returnees who secure faculty positions, leaving limited understanding of how overseas-trained PhDs re-enter academia through postdoctoral appointments and how such positions are lived after return. Drawing on a new materialist assemblage perspective, this duo-ethnographic study examines the postdoctoral becoming of two Chinese PhD returnees working in elite universities in China. The findings are that postdoctoral becoming is assembled through three interrelated processes. First, the postdoctoral appointment operates as an aspirational yet precarious re-entry device, carrying returnees’ hopes of becoming recognised scholars and fears that such recognition may not arrive in time. Second, postdoctoral becoming unfolds through infrastructures of partial legibility and uneven recognition, through which returnees’ academic presence becomes visible only in fragments and their transnational academic capital remains subject to domestic re-certification. Third, mundane objects and everyday routines operate as affective-material supports through which postdocs sustain academic work amid ongoing precarity. The study contributes to higher education research by showing that overseas-trained PhDs’ re-entry into Chinese academia through postdoctoral appointments is not a linear process of reintegration or a straightforward conversion of overseas credentials into domestic advantage. Instead, their postdoctoral trajectories are materially and affectively assembled in ways that make academic futures possible, deferred and unevenly sustained.