Open Economies Review Экономика и эконометрика
When Do Deficits Predict Default? Fiscal Surprises and Sovereign Risk, 2000–2023
Аннотация
Most fiscal rules limit the headline deficit, often to 3% of GDP, and the usual reason given is that bigger deficits make default more likely. I test that reasoning on 185 countries over 2000–2023, using credit events from the Bank of Canada–Bank of England database and sovereign ratings, and separating the part of the deficit the IMF did not expect with fiscal surprises built from 20 archived editions of the IMF World Economic Outlook. Deficits do move debt, ratings and yields, yet I find no deficit level at which default risk jumps. A deficit one point of GDP larger than the IMF forecast a year earlier raises debt by about a quarter of a point for four years and lowers the sovereign rating. Deficits have predicted defaults since 2010, mainly on private creditors and where non-residents hold much of the debt, but not in the 2000s. No deficit threshold separates safe from risky positions; the only break, near balance, is in debt surges. A deficit ceiling protects the debt path, but its level cannot be derived from default risk.