ERA Forum Law

The application of the posting conflict rule after the 2026 Amendment of the Coordination Regulations: prior notification, dialogue and conciliation procedure, and the recent CJEU case law

Carrascosa Bermejo, Dolores
Springer Nature · 2026-09-01 · DOI 10.1007/s12027-026-00896-6

Abstract

After nearly a decade of negotiations, the reform of the EU Social Security Coordination Regulations was finally agreed upon in the 20th trilogue of April 2026. The Amending Regulation is expected to be published in autumn 2026, but the implementation of many of its new provisions has been delayed by 24 months or even larger transitional periods. In the meantime, the Court of Justice has continued to issue relevant case law on the posting of workers and the obligation to engage in the dialogue and conciliation procedure regarding the portable A1 form (PD A1). This article provides a critical analysis of the posting conflict rule and its practical application. It considers the current legal framework, the changes under the Amending Regulation, and recent case law from the CJEU (mainly judgements on cases Zaklad C-422/22 and EX C-421/23). Firstly, the article reviews the procedure for requesting and issuing a posting PD A1. This procedure is currently predominantly carried out online as part of a growing digitalisation process promoted by the Commission and supported by the ELA. It also analyses the requirement for ‘prior notification’ and the set of exceptions to the obligation to request a PD A1. Secondly, it compares the existing and amended criteria that national institutions must follow to determine whether the conflict-of-law requirements are met in order to issue a PD A1, distinguishing between the criteria for employees and self-employed workers. In this regard, the reform codifies some of the non-legally binding Administrative Commission Decisions or Practical Guide provisions and considers certain case law, such as the Alpenrind replacement ban case. Finally, this article addresses the significant changes introduced by the Amending Regulation, in particular with regard to clarifying the implications of an incomplete or missing PD A1. It also refers to the more agile dialogue and conciliation procedure included in the Implementing Regulation. A specific procedure is established for the inter-institutional settlement of contributions and benefits when the applicable legislation changes retroactively. Many of these issues will be governed by Commission implementing acts, which will lay down standardised procedures. Although the reform aims to increase legal certainty, its success will ultimately depend on cooperation and mutual trust between the institutions, which are being strengthened through technology and digitalisation.

Read at publisher →