Cultural Studies of Science Education Cultural Studies
Unlearning the March of Progress: visual ideology and critical visual literacy in evolution education
Abstract
Visual representations encode theoretical assumptions, historical conventions, and cultural values that shape how scientific concepts are understood. In evolution education this is particularly consequential, as the persistent circulation of March of Progress –style imagery in textbooks, posters, and classroom materials reinforces interpretations of evolutionary change as a linear, goal-directed process culminating in modern humans. This article examines how such imagery operates within Mexican educational settings and explores how critical engagement with familiar evolutionary visuals might support situated shifts in students’ representational reasoning in upper-secondary classrooms. The study draws on Gaston Bachelard's notion of epistemological obstacles and on critical visual literacy. Nine commercially available school monographs widely used in Mexico City were analysed along five dimensions—representational structure, visual syntax, modal affordances, epistemic fidelity, and epistemic issues. The same framework was applied to forty-five drawings produced individually by students aged 16–17 over four 90-min sessions, alongside their oral explanations. Eight of the nine monographs reproduced variants of the March of Progress , and their depiction of “modern” humans converged on a strikingly narrow archetype: a young, athletic, light-skinned male body. After the intervention, 38 of 45 student drawings adopted branching rather than linear configurations and 35 represented evolutionary change at the species or population level. Classroom discussions evidenced an emerging metavisual awareness of how design elements direct interpretation, although linear and progressivist features persisted alongside these shifts. The study treats educational images as epistemic and cultural artefacts and shows how critical visual literacy can be enacted in everyday classrooms, treating familiar problematic images as productive sites for representational reflection. Findings are situated and exploratory; observations on the ideological dimensions of evolutionary imagery are offered as an interpretive lens calibrated to the scope of the evidence.