Higher Education Образование

Publication productivity or academic standing? differential career returns to explicit and implicit doctoral capital

Yao, Yuan, Guo, Hui
Springer Nature · 2026-10-22 · DOI 10.1007/s10734-026-01801-3

Аннотация

Quantitative evaluation increasingly shapes doctoral training and competition for faculty positions, yet how visible performance and other doctoral training experiences relate to subsequent career development remains insufficiently understood. Drawing on survey data from 2,148 faculty members with doctoral degrees in the mainland China sample of the Academic Profession in the Knowledge-Based Society (APIKS) project, this study distinguishes explicit and implicit doctoral capital on the basis of institutional visibility. Scholarship acquisition represents the former, while autonomous topic choice and attentive supervisory guidance indirectly represent the latter. The study examines their associations with publication productivity and leadership positions within academic communities. Scholarship acquisition is significantly and positively associated with subsequent publication productivity, but not with community leadership positions. Autonomous topic choice and supervisory guidance are significantly and positively associated with community leadership positions, but not with publication productivity. Subgroup analyses by career-accumulation period and discipline reveal exploratory patterns, but interaction tests provide no stable evidence of differences. The study extends discussions of the career returns to doctoral education to two dimensions: organizational performance evaluation and recognition within professional communities. It also proposes a recursive risk that remains to be tested: by reshaping training and selection, the upstream extension of quantitative evaluation may affect the foundations on which future professional judgment is formed.

Читать у издателя →