Higher Education Policy Социология и политология
Enacting Shadow Policy under Metric Governance in Higher Education
Аннотация
This study examines how metric governance shapes policy enactment within higher education systems characterized by performance-based accountability and policy ambiguity. Drawing on Bourdieusian policy sociology, the paper adopts shadow policy as an analytic concept to explain how informal yet structured governance practices stabilize policy enactment beyond formal policy texts. Based on qualitative interview accounts from senior leaders and Work-Integrated Learning (WIL) practitioners across postsecondary institutions in Alberta, Canada, the study shows that WIL governance operates through the translation of numeric mandates into workable arrangements via classification, capital conversion, and symbolic legitimation. Provincial accountability instruments emphasize expansion targets while leaving substantive questions of quality and form under-specified, displacing interpretive authority to institutions. In response, institutions construct internal definitions and coordination mechanisms that function as de facto policy-in-practice. These processes become routinized over time, shaping legitimacy and access while reproducing inequality through uneven distributions of capital. The paper argues that shadow policy is not merely a response to ambiguity but a constitutive feature of contemporary governance, through which power is exercised and normalized in higher education. While grounded in a single jurisdiction, the findings speak to broader international trends in higher education governance.