Crime Prevention and Community Safety Право
Infrastructure vandalism in developing economies: a systematic review of typologies, drivers, impacts, and governance-oriented prevention strategies
Аннотация
Infrastructure vandalism threatens economic development, service delivery, and institutional stability, yet evidence remains fragmented across contexts and insufficiently integrated into a coherent prevention framework. This systematic review examined 44 research articles and review studies published between 2015 and 2025 to develop an integrated synthesis of the existing evidence. Nine literature-derived typologies were identified: graffiti/tagging, acquisitive, vengeful/vindictive/political, ideological/protest, institutional/organisational, cyber, economic, malicious, and play vandalism, with their frequency varying across the reviewed studies. Recurring drivers included legal and regulatory weaknesses, limited community and stakeholder engagement, insecurity and inadequate guardianship, socio-economic deprivation, limited public awareness, and institutional and environmental deficiencies. The identified impacts encompassed physical infrastructure damage, economic losses, service disruption, environmental degradation, and institutional erosion. Prevention measures included social, situational, environmental, institutional, technological, and integrated approaches, although evidence on their implementation and effectiveness was uneven. The review proposes an integrated conceptual framework linking vandalism typologies and drivers with governance capacity, impacts, and differentiated prevention strategies. The framework provides a basis for context-responsive prevention and future empirical research, while its proposed relationships require further validation through comparative, longitudinal, and mixed-method studies.