Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review Гуманитарные и социальные науки
From collective action to effective demand: John R. Commons and the institutional foundations of monetary capitalism
Аннотация
This article reconstructs John R. Commons’s institutional economics around the formation of expenditure in monetary capitalism and relates it to Keynes’s principle of effective demand. Rather than claiming that Commons anticipated Keynes or possessed an equivalent theory, it asks where their approaches converge and how their analytical constructions differ. Keynes defines effective demand as the expected aggregate proceeds that determine output and employment, with private investment as its strategically volatile component. The article reconstructs from Commons a recursive institutional mechanism through which future-oriented expectations become expenditure: expectations of future income are coordinated through conventions and working rules; represented as property claims and monetary obligations; and converted by credit into present purchasing power. Credit creates monetary capacity, while expected profitability, financing costs, and risk govern whether that capacity is activated. Judicial decisions stabilize enforceable commitments; administrative inquiry and supervision investigate recurring disruptions and formulate prospective rules; and collective democracy incorporates situated knowledge and conflicting valuations into rule formation. Realized expenditure, income, employment, asset values, and performances then feed back into expectations, credit assessments, and working rules, reproducing or transforming the conditions of subsequent commitments. Commons therefore does not redefine effective demand; his categories explain how monetary commitments become credible, financeable, negotiable, enforceable, and sufficiently profitable to generate the expenditure flows on which Keynes’s aggregate constraint operates. The two analyses overlap but remain distinct: Keynes specifies the macroeconomic determination of output and employment, whereas the Commonsian reconstruction explains the recursive formation, activation, and reproduction of expenditure, governed and revised through collective action.