Educational Studies in Mathematics Education
The meaning of task authenticity in elementary school mathematics: students’ perceived authenticity across dimensions of task authenticity
Abstract
This study investigates how sixth-grade students perceive the authenticity of contextualized mathematics tasks. Rather than treating authenticity as a fixed property embedded in task design, it examines authenticity as perceived by learners and analyzes these perceptions across multiple dimensions of task authenticity. Four publicly released PISA mathematics tasks were administered to Grade 6 students in South Korea, and 357 complete responses were analyzed. Students evaluated each task on a 4-point Likert scale across five dimensions—Event, Question, Information, Comprehension, and Solution Strategies—and provided open-ended explanations for their judgments. Quantitative analysis showed that mean authenticity ratings for all four tasks remained below 3.00, with the Car selection task rated highest and the Penguin eggs task rated lowest, and the Solution Strategies dimension generally receiving relatively high ratings across tasks. Qualitative analysis revealed three patterns. Factual realism in the Information dimension did not necessarily coincide with high ratings of the plausibility of the event or question. Perceived authenticity was closely tied to whether students could see a plausible role for themselves in the task situation, either because the situation was close to their own experience or because they could assume a hypothetical role. Authenticity was higher when solution strategies were connected to recognizable decision-making contexts, but remained low when the mathematical question itself was perceived as purposeless within the situation, regardless of the procedure’s perceived usefulness. These findings suggest that students’ perceived authenticity was not uniform across the dimensions of task authenticity and cannot be inferred from a task's resemblance to real-world situations alone.