The Australian Journal of Language and Literacy Гуманитарные и социальные науки
Investigating the commonplaces: A comparison of Ontario, Canada’s programmatic literacy curricula before and after the Ontario human rights commission’s right to read inquiry
Аннотация
Literacy education today is characterized by an aporia where the literacy capabilities demanded of democratic citizenry are known to be more complex than ever before, yet there is a strong movement in literacy education towards a narrow Science of Reading (SoR) with its skills-based instruction. Programmatic curricula, governmentally prepared or sanctioned texts intended for classroom enactment, are political texts that are crucial sites for identifying the constituent actors in literacy education including what knowledge is purported by the state to be of most value. This study investigated programmatic literacy curricula in Ontario, Canada, before and after the Ontario Human Rights Commission’s Right to Read (R2R) inquiry. Ontario provides an informative case because of its longstanding reputation for literacy achievement, its responsibilities regarding linguistic diversity and decolonising education, and the significant influence of the R2R inquiry on curriculum reform. Using an instrumental case study and qualitative content analysis, we examined the Grades 1–8 language curricula released in 2006 and 2023. Data were analysed using Schwab’s curriculum commonplaces of subject matter, teacher, student, and milieu, alongside Heydon and Wang’s curricular paradigms. Findings indicate substantial differences in how the two curricula organise literacy learning, represent teachers and students, and conceptualise curriculum-making, while maintaining some common commitments concerning diversity and learning environments. The study highlights shifts in curriculum orientation following the R2R inquiry and identifies implications for curriculum development, literacy policy, and future research examining relationships between programmatic and classroom curricula. The study contributes insights into contemporary literacy curriculum reform and its implications for education in diverse and democratic societies.