European Journal of Psychology of Education Education
Enhancing knowledge integration in project-based learning: the role of scaffolding and authentic problem design
Abstract
Although project-based learning (PBL) is a widely spread practice in higher education, not enough is known about specific mechanisms of scaffolding knowledge integration. This paper fills this gap by exploring the key relationship between the implementation of PBL, the scaffolding of knowledge integration, and authentic problem design. A mixed-method sequential explanatory design that included 347 undergraduate students in the STEM and humanities fields was used. Participants were assigned to four instructional conditions: a control condition with standard PBL, a cognitive–metacognitive scaffolding condition (CMS), a procedural–motivational scaffolding condition (PMS), and an integrated scaffolding condition (IS) combining all four scaffolding dimensions. ANOVA and structural equation modeling quantitative analysis indicated that students in the integrated scaffolding condition demonstrated a 37% improvement in transfer of learning and a 42% increase in cross-disciplinary application compared to traditional instruction groups. The thematic analysis of student products and semi-structured interviews ( n = 60) identified four main mechanisms through which scaffolding supported knowledge integration. The authenticity dimension of problems is an important mediator between scaffolding practices and learning outcomes. This study presents the Integrated Scaffold-Authenticity Model (ISAM), which describes the interaction of scaffolding dimensions with problem authenticity and their effects on knowledge integration. The results provide solid arguments to support the claim that carefully designed knowledge integration tasks, combined with realistic problem situations, are highly effective in promoting cognitive as well as non-cognitive learning. Teachers can use ISAM when designing curriculum in any discipline, especially in STEM and humanities programs that have cross-disciplinary skills.