Hague Journal on the Rule of Law Law

EU Migration Deals: Border Externalization and the Diffusion of Autocratic Migration Tools

Hoppermann, Judith
Springer Nature · 2026-04-01 · DOI 10.1007/s40803-026-00278-7

Abstract

How does a "democratic," Global North actor like the European Union (EU) advance autocratic migration practices in the Global South? This paper theorizes the link between the EU's border externalization policies and the diffusion of autocratic migration practices in the Middle East. Moving beyond analyses that focus on migration diplomacy and bargaining dynamics in these arrangements, this paper demonstrates that the EU actively drives autocratic migration practices: first, by directly employing autocratic tools in migration policy—such as bypassing parliamentary oversight—to conclude migration deals and second, by incentivizing the adoption of autocratic migration tools, key to enabling autocratic migration practices in transit states through the provision of political and economic rents. These practices target migrants and refugees in refugee-hosting countries through autocratic tools like ambiguity politics and ad hoc migration policies. Methodologically, the paper uses a sited case study approach, comparing two EU migration deals—one with Turkey (2016) and another with Lebanon (2024). Drawing on a diverse array of primary sources in English, German, Turkish, and Arabic—including legal frameworks, court proceedings, press releases, speeches, policy and funding reports, and news articles—the study employs critical discourse analysis to trace the evolution of the EU's stance on autocratic migration practices, restricting migrants’ rights, before and after each deal. In doing so, it demonstrates how the EU's externalization strategy not only bypasses democratic oversight in its own migration policy but also fosters the diffusion of autocratic migration tools and practices across regime types.

Read at publisher →