Punishment through delay: an exploratory study of institutional inequality and time without sentencing in Mexico
Abstract
Delays in judicial processes constitute a form of punitive state action that disproportionately affects individuals subjected to pretrial detention. This article examines punishment through delay by introducing a duration-based measure – time without sentencing – that captures institutional inequality in Mexico’s criminal justice system. Using nationally representative microdata ( n = 54,080) from the 2021 National Survey of the Population Deprived of Liberty (ENPOL), we apply event-history methods to estimate how long individuals remain incarcerated without receiving a judicial sentence. Results reveal a weighted national median of 1.61 years, rising to 2.08 years under mandatory pretrial detention (MPD) and 1.21 years under non-mandatory regimes. Descriptively, 32.2% of total incarceration time among the incarcerated population observed in ENPOL 2021 occurred before sentencing, suggesting that pretrial detention may operate in practice, within the incarcerated population observed, as a substantive penal sanction rather than solely as a precautionary measure. Substantial territorial disparities emerge across Mexico’s 32 states: median times range from under one year to more than five years for MPD cases in the slowest jurisdictions, mirroring structural inequalities in judicial capacity and state presence. By reframing duration as a measure of institutional performance, this study illustrates how punitive delay operates unevenly across legal regimes and geographic contexts, producing differentiated access to justice. As an exploratory study, this article introduces a replicable measurement framework and opens new avenues for research on pretrial detention as a mechanism of institutional inequality, contributing to criminological debates on state capacity, procedural justice, and the expanding reach of pretrial incarceration.