Behavior Analysis in Practice Humanities and social sciences
Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) in Public Healthcare: Professional Profiles and Regulatory Contexts in Italy and the USA
Abstract
Applied behavior analysis (ABA), the applied branch of the science of behavior, has generated widely recognized evidence-based interventions for autism spectrum disorder, and several countries have incorporated ABA-based practices into their public healthcare systems. The implementation of professional services, however, varies significantly with differences in legal frameworks, educational systems, and healthcare infrastructures. This paper presents a comparative analysis of ABA-based service delivery in Italy and the United States (USA), situated within the broader European landscape of professional recognition, and examines how professional practice functions within distinct regulatory contexts. In the USA, behavior analysis has emerged as an autonomous profession through standardized certification (BCBA^®) and state-level licensure, a credential that acquires legal effect because state law incorporates it. In Italy, by contrast, the legal framework does not provide a pathway for recognition of behavior analysis as a standalone profession, a configuration that is structural rather than transitional, since the activities involved fall within the scope of practice already assigned by law to regulated health professions. Behavior-analytic competencies have consequently developed within the established roles of psychologists, speech-language pathologists, professional educators, and other regulated health professionals. The Italian experience documents how, in the absence of a dedicated legal framework, existing academic and professional infrastructures can sustain the delivery of behavior-analytic services within current regulatory constraints. The case illustrates that documented competence within existing professions and formal recognition as a distinct profession are separable, and that the first has proved achievable where the second has not. Certification and licensure do different work: a privately issued credential attests competence, whereas the legal right to practice is conferred by national or state law. Establishing which of the two is at stake in a given jurisdiction is the first step in judging whether a credentialing model developed elsewhere can be transferred there. Recognition of behavior analysis in Europe has taken three distinct forms: an autonomous health profession, a specialization within an already regulated profession, and a profession-led register without statutory force. Which of these is available in a given country depends on whether an existing regulated profession already holds the relevant scope of practice, so arrangements that look dissimilar in form may be functionally equivalent, and arrangements that share a name may not be. In Italy, the professional title determines the scope of autonomy and behavior-analytic training determines competence within it. Psychologists and physicians specialized in psychiatry who hold documented behavior-analytic training may supervise; other regulated professionals apply behavior-analytic procedures within their own professional competence and under supervision. Comparable functions may be distributed differently across professional profiles in other national systems. In Italy, where no degree class in behavior analysis exists, post-degree programs have been the operative route to competence. In this context, such programs are assessed on their content and on the verification they have undergone, rather than on any capacity to confer a professional title, which only the State can do. Where degree structures and titling rules differ, the weight carried by post-degree training will differ accordingly. In Italy, a professional board can define and verify qualification criteria without legislative change, as the register established by the Lazio Board of Psychologists shows, making competence visible to families and public purchasers while leaving the professional title unchanged. What a professional board is empowered to do varies considerably across countries, so the instrument that performs this function elsewhere may take a different legal form, or rest with a different body altogether.