Journal of Consumer Policy Economics and Econometrics
Trading One Confusion for Another: Side Effects of Plant-Based Label Modifications
Abstract
Policy makers are currently grappling with how to label plant-based analogues of animal products (e.g., veggie burgers). One of the main reasons for the labeling controversy revolves around potential confusion about current product labels. While there are many different potential kinds of confusion, we focus on confusion about the primary ingredients of plant-based meat analogues. We tested changes to labels based on some current Food and Drug Administration recommendations that include specifying the primary ingredient in the product name on the principal display panel. In two experiments (N = 196, 194), we provide evidence that including the primary ingredient on the label increased accuracy of identifying the primary ingredient of the product, but often not more than if the nutrition facts panel was included. However, people became less accurate at identifying other ingredients the product contained that were not primary ingredients. We also found little evidence that providing the primary ingredient of the product increased the accuracy of identifying key nutritional content of the products (e.g., protein content), but including the nutrition facts panel made people more accurate at identifying nutritional content of the products. These data suggest that changes that include providing the primary ingredient in the product name will not change accuracy beyond current labeling practices that include the nutrition facts panel and may carry some unintended risk for generating confusion about product ingredients. These label changes, similar to the recommendations from the FDA, may impact consumer and animal welfare.