Medical Science Educator Education
Flipped Hybrid Peer-Teaching Simulation Among MSN Students: Building Graduate-Level Clinical Reasoning in Undergraduate Teaching Practice
Abstract
Background Master of Science in Nursing (MSN) students enter undergraduate teaching practica without structured pedagogical training. They tend to teach the way they were taught, by lecture, which limits the quality of clinical reasoning instruction reaching the next generation of nurses. Innovation This study introduces and evaluates the Flipped Hybrid Peer-Teaching Simulation (FHPTS) model, a five-step pedagogy in which MSN students prepare content through pre-class videos, design and facilitate low-fidelity simulation scenarios for undergraduate peers, and engage in Debriefing for Meaningful Learning (DML) followed by structured reflective journaling. Unlike prior peer-teaching or flipped-classroom work, FHPTS places the MSN student simultaneously in the learner and teacher role, and measures both clinical reasoning and pedagogical self-efficacy as paired outcomes. Methods A quasi-experimental pre–post design with a parallel control group was conducted across one 16-week semester (FHPTS n = 30; control n = 30). Outcomes were measured using the Health Sciences Reasoning Test (HSRT), the Nurse Educator Self-Efficacy Scale (NESES), and the Pedagogical Self-Efficacy Inventory (PSI). Reflective journals were coded using an adaptation of Kember and colleagues’ (1999) empirically tested operationalization of Mezirow’s content–process–premise categories (κ = 0.82). The study evaluated FHPTS as a combined pedagogical package; it was not designed to isolate flipped learning, peer teaching, or simulation as independent factors. Results FHPTS participants gained 7.8 HSRT points compared with 3.2 in the control group (between-group d = 1.29). NESES scores rose by 25.7 versus 12.3 points ( d = 1.73). PSI post-test scores were 10.6 points higher in FHPTS ( d = 1.63). Premise-level reflection grew from 14 to 48% across the eight units. These are large effects on reasoning and self-reported teaching confidence; they are not direct measures of teaching effectiveness or of undergraduate learning. Implications FHPTS produced simultaneous gains in clinical reasoning, teaching confidence, and pedagogical self-efficacy. Direct financial outlay was modest (< USD 600), but faculty time for video production, scenario design, DML training, weekly debriefing, and undergraduate-program coordination is substantial and should be planned for. The model is transferable to MSN programs with a basic simulation facility and addresses NLN nurse-educator and AACN graduate essentials.