Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology Экология, эволюция, поведение и систематика

A female-specific plumage trait in relation to individual quality, reproductive success, and male parental effort

Davidson-Onsgard, August, Webster, Michael S., Kaiser, Sara A.
Springer Nature · 2026-10-26 · DOI 10.1007/s00265-026-03816-3

Аннотация

Ornaments are conspicuous traits used for attracting mates and competing with rivals. Historically, these traits were almost exclusively studied in males but are now understood to also function as signals of quality in females. However, most examples are reduced male traits and few studies have examined ornaments unique to females. We investigated whether female-specific plumage traits are honest signals of individual quality in the sexually dichromatic and biparental black-throated blue warbler ( Setophaga caerulescens ). In 2021–2023, we measured the white superciliums of 89 females at the Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, NH, USA. We found that female superciliums vary in size ranging 8–36 mm^2, as well as vary in brightness, but do not appear to signal individual quality or predict reproductive success. Specifically, we found no significant association between the supercilium and female age, body size, reproductive success, or parental effort. Males paired with females with brighter superciliums had territories with lower estimated prey abundance and brought a greater biomass of prey to their nestlings, but both of these results were based on a limited sample size and may not be biologically significant. Our study provides a rare investigation of a female-specific plumage trait, and shows that superciliums can vary considerably among females independent of age or body size. However, our findings do not support a signaling function for this trait. Many female animals express reduced versions of elaborate male traits. These ornaments can advertise individual quality. However, few studies have examined traits unique to females. Male black-throated blue warblers have a uniform black mask, whereas females have white superciliums that vary considerably in size and brightness. At the extreme, some females have superciliums over four times larger than other females. However, we found no strong evidence that these female-specific traits signal individual quality, predict reproductive success, or are related to male parental effort.

Читать у издателя →