Systemic Practice and Action Research Management of Technology and Innovation

Toward an Integrated Critical Systems Practice and Soft System Dynamics Framework for Small-to-Medium Private Enterprise Inclusion in Indonesia’s Renewable Energy Transition: A Conceptual Framework and Systematic Literature Review

Mayrizal, Rony, Hermawan, Pri, Hutajulu, Sahat
Springer Nature · 2026-11-17 · DOI 10.1007/s11213-026-09787-w

Abstract

Small renewable energy entrepreneurs in Indonesia struggle to join national projects because current policies favor large developers. For example, small-scale solar firms often fail to qualify for PLN tenders that require at least Rp 50 billion in paid-up capital and high bank guarantees. This study is conceptual and review-based: it does not report an empirical intervention but instead develops and theoretically justifies an integrated methodological framework that combines Critical Systems Practice (CSP) and Soft System Dynamics Methodology (SSDM). CSP focuses on reflecting critically on power relations and boundaries in decision-making, while SSDM uses participatory modeling to simulate how policies and behaviors interact over time. Together, they offer a structured way to examine why smaller actors remain marginalized despite supportive policy goals. Using a systematic literature review and a ten-step framework built around the Explore–Produce–Intervene–Check (EPIC) cycle, this research identifies common institutional barriers and proposes a framework through which pathways for inclusion can subsequently be modeled. The framework is offered as a theoretical and methodological contribution; its empirical application to a specific Indonesian case is identified as the principal direction for future research. The integrated approach offers conceptual tools for diagnosing exclusion, structuring participatory analysis, and designing adaptive governance strategies that promote fairer participation in Indonesia’s renewable energy transition.

Read at publisher →