Educational technology research and development Образование
A resilience-oriented VR safe-sandbox for FDM 3D printing education: reducing cost-of-failure pressure in early procedural learning
Аннотация
Fused deposition modeling (FDM) 3D printing has become increasingly important in STEM and design education, yet introductory training in shared laboratories often exposes learners to high cost-of-failure conditions, including material waste, equipment downtime, and intensive instructor support. These constraints make procedural error recovery effortful, increase time pressure, and can destabilize early procedural learning. To address this challenge, this study proposes recoverability as an instructional design mechanism and develops a resilience-oriented virtual reality (VR) safe-sandbox that functions as pre-laboratory scaffolding. The environment constrains novice decision spaces, externalizes canonical failure states through explicit diagnostic feedback, and enables reversible, low-cost recovery actions to reduce recovery burden before authentic hands-on practice. A randomized between-subjects experiment involving 150 learners compared the VR safe-sandbox with a conventional physical-interface workflow under matched instructional content. Learners completed standardized introductory FDM training and were evaluated using usability, multidimensional workload, technology acceptance, threshold-based analyses, and Facilitator Intervention Load (FIL). Compared with the physical-interface workflow, the VR condition demonstrated higher usability, lower subjective workload, and more favorable technology acceptance. The largest improvement was observed in Temporal Demand (Hedges' g = −0.99), together with substantial reductions in Effort and Frustration, whereas self-rated Performance and Behavioral Intention remained comparable across conditions. Threshold-based analyses further demonstrated fewer high-strain learner states and reduced facilitator intervention requirements. These findings support a mechanism-oriented interpretation in which recoverability reduces perceived recovery burden, stabilizes learner progression, and improves early procedural learning without replacing authentic laboratory practice. Beyond evaluating a specific VR application, this study introduces a resilience-oriented instructional framework and evidence-based design principles that position recoverability as a transferable instructional design objective for technology-enhanced procedural learning in authentic resource-constrained educational environments.