When heritage shapes fit in brand extensions: evidence from Disney’s live-action films
Аннотация
Reproductive experiential brand extensions raise a question that prevailing accounts of brand extension fit do not fully answer. Traditional fit models rely on criteria such as category- and feature-based similarity and functional complementarity, while research on experiential extensions and brand heritage acknowledges tensions between fidelity and change without specifying which elements audiences treat as binding and which as open to reinterpretation. We distinguish two qualitatively distinct heritage-based fit standards rather than points on a single continuum: strict fit, under which deviation is treated as violating preservation expectations, and flexible fit, under which it may be legitimised as adaptation. Using 35,958 consumer reviews of 15 Disney live-action films, we combine aspect-based sentiment analysis with theoretically specified heritage anchors and dictionary-based measurement. Strict-fit activation is stronger in evaluations anchored in stability and longevity than in those anchored in adaptability, while one clear departure and one boundary case indicate that the standard activated is further qualified at the aspect level. The study therefore locates the boundary between preservation and reinterpretation: fit concerns the selective negotiability of heritage-anchored elements rather than overall similarity or a fidelity–change trade-off. For managers, it identifies where creative deviation carries evaluative risk and where it is legitimised.