An Organizational Perspective on the Evolution of Human Musicality
Аннотация
Despite decades of research, no consensus has emerged regarding why music evolved in humans. Existing evolutionary accounts—including sexual selection, social bonding, parent–infant communication, group coordination, emotional regulation and cognitive by-products—have generated substantial empirical support, yet they are typically presented as competing explanations. This competitive framing has obscured the possibility that these hypotheses describe complementary functions operating within a higher-order adaptive organization rather than mutually exclusive evolutionary scenarios. Here we argue that the current debate is constrained by the absence of an organizational level of explanation capable of integrating these diverse functional contributions into a coherent evolutionary framework. We propose an organizational perspective in which music is understood as an adaptive system that coordinates multiple cognitive, affective and social processes across different temporal and behavioural scales. Within this perspective, we develop the Adaptive Cognitive Tool hypothesis as one empirically testable interpretation. Rather than attributing musical evolution to a single selective pressure, this hypothesis proposes that music enhanced human adaptive capacity by dynamically organizing attention, prediction, memory, emotional regulation, motor synchronization and social coordination, thereby improving behavioural flexibility in complex and changing environments. This perspective generates testable predictions, reconciles apparently conflicting evolutionary hypotheses and suggests that the remarkable universality and multifunctionality of music are expected consequences of its integrative organizational role. More broadly, it illustrates how organizational explanations may complement traditional adaptationist approaches in understanding the evolution of complex human behaviours.