Quality, not conscience: an informative null on what a “Made in Italy” label transfers

Aichner, Thomas
Journal of Marketing Analytics · Springer Nature · 2026-10-28 · DOI: 10.1057/s41270-026-00560-5

Abstract

Origin labels are increasingly enlisted as sustainability arguments, on the assumption that a country's environmental reputation transfers to products made there. We test that assumption at the level of the advertising firm and report an informative null. In a two-condition, three-country advertising experiment (Italy, Germany, United States; N = 1362), an uncertified “Made in Italy” origin label left perceived environmental and social sustainability of the advertising firm unchanged on average. Equivalence tests reject composite effects of ±0.20 standard deviations or larger, pooled and among Italian respondents, although at ±0.10 only the pooled environmental dimension is bounded. Bayes factors favour the null, but the evidence is moderate rather than strong under a prior matched to our own smallest effect of interest. The same label raised perceived quality among Italian consumers, which argues against measurement failure. Tested directly, the asymmetry between the two outcomes is decisive only in Italy. Country sustainability reputations differ clearly and are strongly home-biased, but they did not transfer to the perceived sustainability of an unfamiliar firm in an apparel advertisement.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles