Biology & Philosophy Humanities and social sciences

One kind of adaptationism

Novick, Rose
Springer Nature · 2026-03-16 · DOI 10.1007/s10539-026-10014-y

Abstract

There is only one kind of adaptationism: explanatory adaptationism. Explanatory adaptationism claims that adaptation is the “big question” in evolutionary biology and that natural selection is the “big answer” to that question. In recent decades, philosophers of biology have largely come to agree, first, that explanatory adaptationism is only one kind of adaptationism among many (at the high end, seven) and, second, that these kinds are logically independent and so can, in principle, be accepted or rejected in any combination. On the surface, this is true. Beneath the surface, it is not. When the arguments supporting various forms of allegedly non-explanatory adaptationism are interrogated closely, each turns out to essentially rely on explanatory adaptationism. That is, all kinds of adaptationism are justificatorily dependent on explanatory adaptationism. The different kinds of adaptationism should be recognized as different ways of articulating the import of explanatory adaptationism. In the last analysis, every adaptationist is an explanatory adaptationist.

Read at publisher →