Online product ratings drive sales, prompting managers to constantly seek ways to improve them. While traditional research compares high-rated reviews against low-rated ones (e.g., 5 stars vs. 1 star), this study investigates the subtler, yet critical, distinction between “best” (5-star) and “second-best” (4-star) reviews. We provide novel insights for managers striving to elevate “good” products to “great” ones. Our framework highlights two dimensions of evaluation: the product (hedonic vs. utilitarian) and the consumer (affect vs. cognition). We hypothesize that achieving the highest rating is significantly harder for products perceived as high-risk, low-affect, or high-cognition. Furthermore, we examine how these effects are moderated by three key interactions: Affect × Cognition, Product Type × Cognition, and Product Type × Risk. Empirical analysis of a 15-year dataset of Amazon reviews across 19 product categories supports our hypotheses. A secondary application in the hotel industry further identifies specific amenities that can help managers raise their product ratings from 4 to 5.
Kim, Moon-Yong, Moon, Sangkil, Jenkins, Mason. Consumer-Perceived Differences between Best- and Second-Best-Rated Product Reviews. // Customer Needs and Solutions. – 2026. – DOI: 10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3. – URL: http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3
Kim, Moon-Yong, Moon, Sangkil, Jenkins, & Mason (2026). Consumer-Perceived Differences between Best- and Second-Best-Rated Product Reviews. Customer Needs and Solutions. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3
Kim, et al. “Consumer-Perceived Differences between Best- and Second-Best-Rated Product Reviews.” Customer Needs and Solutions, 2026. doi:10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3.
@article{Kim2026,
title = {Consumer-Perceived Differences between Best- and Second-Best-Rated Product Reviews},
author = {Kim and Moon-Yong and Moon and Sangkil and Jenkins and Mason},
journal = {Customer Needs and Solutions},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3},
url = {http://link.springer.com/openurl/fulltext?id=doi:10.1007/s40547-026-00162-3}
}
The diffusion of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping the competitive architecture of small and medium enterprises (SMEs), yet the extent to which AI adoption is associated with measurable competitive advantage among...
This study draws on Uses and Gratifications Theory (UGT), the MAIN model, and prior OTT service research to examine key factors associated with consumer satisfaction with OTT SVOD platforms, focusing on entertainment, escape, modality,...
This study investigates the safe-haven resilience of Gold, the US dollar (USD), and Bitcoin against four systemic tail risks—stock market volatility (VIX), oil market volatility (OVX), geopolitical risk (GPR), and climate risk—over the...
NA. Tanzania’s sisal exports are an important source of foreign exchange and rural income, but their value is volatile, reflecting global demand cycles, competition from synthetic fibres, climatic variability and domestic supply...
Financial literacy, whether perceived subjectively or objectively assessed, is widely recognized as important for sound financial management; however, it does not consistently translate into disciplined action. This knowledge–behavior...