Higher Education Education

Stable instability: parallel admission regimes and stratified legitimacy in higher education

Garipağaoğlu, Burçak Çağla
Springer Nature · 2026-11-06 · DOI 10.1007/s10734-026-01772-5

Abstract

This study examines how differentiated admission regimes are experienced, interpreted, and negotiated within higher education institutions where multiple entry pathways coexist. Drawing on a qualitative narrative inquiry design, it explores how actors situated in distinct institutional positions such as domestic students, international students, refugee-background students, faculty members, parents, and administrators make sense of parallel admission systems operating within the same organizational space. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 31 participants across five universities in Türkiye and analyzed using narrative thematic analysis. Türkiye provides a theoretically revealing context because merit-based national examination, international admission, humanitarian access, and market-oriented recruitment coexist within the same higher education system, bringing otherwise distinct evaluative principles into direct comparison among actors sharing institutional spaces. Findings reveal that admission is not experienced as a singular or uniform process, but as a landscape of parallel evaluative regimes. Participants engage in continuous comparative sensemaking, through which effort, merit, opportunity, and deservingness are evaluated across admission categories. Although institutional rationales are generally perceived as procedurally intelligible, they rarely resolve questions of fairness. Instead, legitimacy emerges as a relational and context-dependent construction, shaped through ongoing comparison rather than fixed evaluative criteria. Building on these findings, the study develops the concept of stable instability to capture how organizational continuity is maintained despite persistent moral and evaluative tension. It shows that stability in higher education admission systems does not depend on consensus, but on the normalization of unresolved plurality. By foregrounding narrative accounts of multiple stakeholders, the study contributes to literature on institutional complexity, legitimacy, and higher education access, highlighting how differentiated admission regimes generate both organizational stability and sustained interpretive labor within institutions.

Read at publisher →