Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries Aquatic Science

From density to bioenergetics: approaches for estimating fish rearing capacity in freshwater streams

Bond, Morgan H., Copeland, Timothy, Naman, Sean M., Benjamin, Joseph R., Bellmore, J. Ryan, See, Kevin E., Beechie, Tim, Greene, Correigh, Bayer, Jennifer M., Dethloff, Meg, Scranton, Russell
Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI 10.1007/s11160-026-10109-5

Abstract

Fish ecologists and managers have an interest in estimating the efficacy of freshwater habitat restoration, comparing among restoration options and basins. This often boils down to the question: How many fish can this habitat support? The number of fish a habitat can support, termed capacity, has increasingly become the currency for comparing habitats, restoration options, management policies, and is the backbone of many life cycle models. Underlying this focus is the assumption that capacity is determined from a factor or factors that limit abundance, and that improving these factors will promote an increase in population abundance. Researchers have a number of methods to estimate capacity, each with different benefits and drawbacks that vary by situation. Broadly, these methods fall into five categories: habitat expansion —applying high percentile observed fish densities to estimates of habitat area or volume; stock-recruit —fitting statistical relationships to time series of paired adult and progeny abundance; quantile regression —fitting high percentile regressions to local estimates of fish abundance and habitat features; microhabitat-scale models —scaling up statistical microhabitat suitability or individual bioenergetic requirements to reach and population levels; and food web models —estimating the energy flow from the primary and secondary production in a stream environment up through food webs to fish. The appropriate method in each situation will be determined by the available data, what management questions are being evaluated, the urgency and cost of producing estimates, and the temporal and spatial scales of estimates required.

Read at publisher →