Decoupling at variable speeds: evidence of hidden thresholds and driver dynamics in material intensity along development paths
Аннотация
Achieving decoupling requires a clear understanding of how material intensity changes at variable speeds along development paths, accelerating, stalling, or plunging at different stages rather than following a uniform decline. Evidence on this relationship remains scattered and is often constrained by assumed functional forms. We compile a comprehensive panel: production-based Domestic Material Consumption (DMC) and consumption-based Material Footprint (MF) for 107 countries (1970–2016), matched with three development indicators—GDP per capita, the Human Development Index (HDI), and a Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) Index. Employing multi-threshold panel regressions, we let the data reveal hidden thresholds that separate distinct decoupling regimes. Along the HDI path, DMC/GDP drops faster after a country moves from low to medium HDI, whereas MF/GDP accelerates only after the shift from medium to high HDI. Along the SDG path, two thresholds appear: intensity falls quickly at first, slows at mid-range scores, and plunges again after a higher SDG benchmark. Driver dynamics also reorganize. In early development, population growth raises intensity, while human capital, urbanization, technology, trade openness, and industrialization lower it; technology’s mitigating effect is roughly twice that of trade openness. In advanced stages, industrialization becomes an upward force, and trade openness cuts intensity nearly twice as much as technology. These findings suggest that material efficiency policies should be stage-sensitive: countries below the identified thresholds should prioritize human capital, basic urban infrastructure, and clean technology diffusion, while countries beyond the thresholds should emphasize circular economy systems, dematerializing innovation, and trade channels that accelerate the diffusion of resource-efficient technologies. The insights sharpen our grasp of global resource stewardship and provide guidance on pursuing development within planetary limits.