Are Macro Shocks Second Order?

Journal of Youth and Adolescence · Springer Nature · 2026-10-19 · DOI: 10.1007/s41549-026-00143-4

Аннотация

This paper addresses two fundamental macroeconomics questions. First, are macro shocks large enough to alter the course of the economy? Second, are they large enough to materially impact economic welfare? Lucas and many others have addressed these issues, but do so primarily in the context of representative agent models. We study these questions using a large-scale, general equilibrium, stochastic, overlapping generations model. We consider 80 generations overlapping in an economy buffeted by realistically calibrated total factor productivity and capital depreciation shocks. The model is solved using Marcet’s projection method taking explicit account of the full state space, which comprises 81 variables. Our findings, some recapitulated from prior studies by Hasanhodzic and Kotlikoff, suggest macro shocks are second order both with respect to their impact on aggregate variables and individual welfare. Specifically, the probability that the stochastic economy’s long-run aggregates materially deviate from their deterministic counterparts is less than one percent. Furthermore, the realized (simulated) lifetime utility of generations born in the long run rarely differs from deterministic long-run utility levels by more than 1 percent, measured as consumption-compensating differentials. These findings are supported by the model’s small equity premium. Moreover, adding a bond market leaves our findings essentially unchanged. Our RBC-in-OLG findings suggest that what really impacts economic welfare is not macro shocks, but government policy, particularly intergenerational redistribution policy. Our paper comprises, in the tradition of Edward Leamer, a specification search, but one involving alternative theory and computation, not alternative estimators. And, like so much of Leamer’s work, it’s iconoclastic. It shows that large-scale, life-cycle macro models can be computed as readily as intergenerationally altruistic representative agent models, which have, regrettably, come to dominate all aspects of macroeconomic research.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи