Trial-and-error during early host-range expansion: demographic constraints underlying asymmetric host use in a leaf beetle
Аннотация
Host-range expansion is a key evolutionary process underlying ecological specialization, diversification, sometimes even contributing to ecological speciation in herbivorous insects. However, its earliest stages remain poorly documented under natural conditions, particularly with respect to failed colonization attempts. Here, we report a field-based case of trial-and-error during early host-range expansion in the leaf beetle Galerucella grisescens (Joannis) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) in northern Kyushu, Japan. A dense population of G. grisescens showed a transient outbreak on the invasive aquatic plant Myriophyllum aquaticum (Vell.) Verdc. (Haloragaceae), indicating successful completion of generations on this newly adopted host plant, which is phylogenetically distant from its traditional polygonaceous hosts. Following the depletion of this resource, some individuals shifted feeding to a neighboring native aquatic plant Ludwigia peploides subsp. stipulacea (Ohwi) P.H.Raven. Although feeding damage was observed on L. peploides subsp. stipulacea , laboratory rearing experiments revealed extremely rapid larval mortality, preventing population establishment. These contrasting outcomes, i.e., demographic success on an invasive plant and demographic failure on a native plant despite apparent feeding, demonstrate pronounced asymmetry in early host-range expansion. Our results provide rare empirical evidence that ecological fitting can enable transient plant exploitation while demographic constraints act as strong filters against colonization. This study highlights that early host-range expansion is characterized by frequent failures and that feeding alone does not constitute evolutionary host use.