The Sandeel Case (EU v. UK): the role of Article 63(1) UNCLOS in the management of shared stocks in the context of climate change
Аннотация
The Sandeel Case between the European Union (EU) and the United Kingdom (UK), concerning the UK’s prohibition of industrial sandeel fishing was decided by an arbitral tribunal on 28 April 2025. Although the dispute arose under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), this article argues that the tribunal missed an important opportunity to examine the implications of Article 63(1) of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the principal provision governing the conservation and management of shared stocks. It argues that Article 63(1) applies to shared stocks irrespective of their migratory behavior and imposes a continuing due diligence obligation requiring States to engage in meaningful negotiations in good faith and remain willing to adapt existing arrangements in response to changing circumstances. Drawing on the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea’s Climate Change Advisory Opinion, the article further contends that this obligation becomes increasingly stringent where shared stocks are impacted by climate change. Against this legal framework, the article analyses the Parties’ positions in the Sandeel Case and highlights the need to clarify how unilateral conservation measures adopted in response to climate change interact with States’ obligations to cooperate in the management of shared fish stocks.