Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries Aquatic Science
Multifaceted freshwater fish α-diversity exhibits discordant spatial patterns and distinct environmental associations across the United States
Abstract
Understanding how different dimensions of biodiversity vary across environmental gradients is important for characterizing large-scale patterns of freshwater biodiversity. Taxonomic diversity (TD), functional diversity (FD), and phylogenetic diversity (PD) describe different facets of biological communities and may exhibit either concordant or divergent spatial patterns. However, their relative spatial patterns and environmental associations in freshwater fish assemblages remain insufficiently understood at the continental scale. In this study, we integrated distribution data, functional traits, and phylogenetic information for 786 native freshwater fish species across 1873 watersheds in the contiguous United States to quantify TD, FD, and PD. Boosted Regression Tree models (BRTs) were used to assess the associations of these three diversity facets with contemporary climate, historical climatic change, and geographical factors. The three diversity facets exhibited pronounced spatial heterogeneity and partial spatial incongruence, with distinct patterns of association with environmental variables. TD exhibited a clear west–east gradient, with lower values in the western U.S. and higher values in the central and eastern regions. It was most strongly associated with precipitation during the warmest quarter, and the BRT model explained 86.9% of the observed variation. FD hotspots were concentrated along the Pacific and Atlantic coasts and in the Florida Peninsula, whereas most watersheds in the Central Plains showed relatively low FD. FD was most strongly associated with elevation and the change in mean annual temperature since the Last Glacial Maximum (LGMT), with the model explaining 65.5% of the variation. PD hotspots were distributed along the Atlantic Coast, the Florida Peninsula, and the Great Lakes region. Similar to FD, PD was most strongly associated with elevation and LGMT, with the model explaining 53.1% of the variation. Overall, the three diversity facets showed only partial spatial congruence and differed in their environmental associations, indicating that large-scale patterns of freshwater fish biodiversity are not fully captured by species richness alone. These findings provide complementary perspectives on freshwater fish biodiversity and may inform biodiversity assessment and conservation planning by considering taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic dimensions alongside contemporary environmental gradients and historical climatic legacies.