International Journal of Plant Production Агрономия и растениеводство
Integrating Emergy, Economic Indices, Sensitivity Analysis, and Water Footprint to Assess the Sustainability of Major Crops in the Lake Urmia Basin, Iran
Аннотация
This study evaluated the sustainability of major fall (wheat, barley, rapeseed, alfalfa) and spring (sugar beet, sunflower, fodder corn, tomato) crops in the Lake Urmia basin, Iran, using emergy indicators, economic analysis, and water footprint assessment in 2023–2024. Descriptive comparison of emergy indicators showed crop-specific differences in efficiency-related performance, with alfalfa, rapeseed, and fodder corn showing relatively favorable values for selected indicators. According to the Environmental Loading Ratio, wheat and barley imposed a high environmental burden, while other crops were classified as medium-burden and semi-sustainable. Alfalfa had the highest Emergy Renewability, indicating slightly greater sustainability than the remaining crops. However, all crops had Environmental Sustainability Index (ESI) values below 1, reflecting unfavorable environmental performance and high energy use (ESI < 1 = high environmental impact). The Emergy Index of Agricultural Product Safety showed that the health status of most fall crops was more favorable than that of spring crops. Economic results identified alfalfa as the most profitable fall crop, while sugar beet and tomato generated the highest net income among spring crops. Sensitivity analysis indicated that reducing irrigation water (10–20%), fossil fuel use (20–40%), and nitrogen fertilizer (25–50%)—combined with partial substitution by organic inputs—enhanced the efficiency and sustainability of all crops while lowering environmental pressure. Water footprint analysis revealed that blue water dominated total footprint contributions; alfalfa and fodder corn had the lowest footprints among fall and spring crops, respectively. Overall, reducing fossil fuel and chemical fertilizer dependence, improving irrigation efficiency, and replacing high-burden crops like rapeseed and sunflower can advance sustainable agriculture in the basin.