Current Psychology General Psychology

Development and preliminary evaluation of the counseling impostor scale-short form (CIS-10)

Clarke, Brian J.
Springer Nature · 2026-11-20 · DOI 10.1007/s12144-026-10364-6

Abstract

Counselor impostor phenomenon (CIP) involves persistent self-doubt and difficulty internalizing professional competence. Lengthy measures can limit research involving multiple constructs or repeated assessment. This study derived a 10-item short form of the Counseling Impostor Scale (CIS-10) and evaluated its properties as the items functioned within the full instrument. Ten items were drawn from the original three content domains to balance psychometric strength, content coverage, and brevity. A sample of 235 counselors-in-training and licensed counselors completed the full CIS and related measures. Ordered-categorical confirmatory factor analyses favored a correlated three-factor model representing Self-Doubt, Fraud/Luck, and Praise Adverse over a strict one-factor model and a two-factor model combining Self-Doubt and Fraud/Luck. Overall fit was mixed: scaled CFI = 0.990, RMSEA = 0.089, and SRMR = 0.041; robust CFI = 0.958 and RMSEA = 0.104. An exploratory structural equation model retained the intended primary-loading pattern while allowing cross-loadings. CIS-10 scores correlated with general impostor phenomenon ( r = .823), self-compassion ( r = − .559), psychological distress (r = .510), and perfectionism dimensions (Evaluative Concerns, r = .474; Striving, r = .352). An exploratory comparison showed higher scores among counselors-in-training, with interpretation limited by untested measurement invariance. Findings provide preliminary evidence for the embedded ten-item composite. Further evaluation under standalone administration is needed.

Read at publisher →