Urban Ecosystems Ecology

Trait-associated and community-level patterns in tropical bird assemblages across urban–rural locations: a spatial machine-learning approach in central Nigeria

Ojochenemi, Oseni Solomon, Ekwemuka, Michael C., Bawa, Deborah, Christopher, Monday, Chinweike, Amobi Anselem, Oche, Onoja Peter, Jeremiah, Faith Jesutofunmi, Ekeoma, Ukabiala Maduabuchi, Keke, Unique N.
Springer Nature · 2026-11-04 · DOI 10.1007/s11252-026-02167-1

Abstract

Urban expansion is changing bird assemblages across sub-Saharan Africa, where the sorting of species along urban–rural gradients is understudied. We present a multi-scale analysis of bird assemblages at four locations in Minna, central Nigeria, combining trait-environment modelling, ordination, beta-diversity analysis and machine learning. We recorded 115 species (15 orders, 50 families) in 71 single-visit, 10-minute, fixed-radius point counts (April to July 2021). Because locations were sampled at different times, location and season are partly confounded. Bird detection was weakly predicted (AUC = 0.676): generalists and frugivorous birds were more likely to be detected at multiple stations compared to specialists. Abundance where detected was weakly predicted (R² = 0.133) and higher among seed-eating species. Trait-environment interactions did not improve prediction, indicating trait-associated detection rather than trait-mediated environmental filtering. No community metric was predictable at a withheld location, and no feeding-guild model had predictive skill. Composition differed among locations (PERMANOVA pseudo-F = 1.68, R² = 0.070, p = 0.001), although dispersion also differed and the three locations surveyed within nine days did not differ significantly. Beta-diversity was mostly explained by replacement (0.65) compared to nestedness (0.07). Shannon diversity and functional dispersion were lowest in Gidan Kwano, whereas richness did not differ, even after rarefaction. Composition was associated with tree density, tree size, and elevation, yet not independent from geographic distance. Turnover-driven replacement suggests that networks of habitat patches would provide better protection of regional diversity, which should be confirmed through repeated surveys at same seasons.

Read at publisher →