Journal of Population Research Медицина (общая)
Reproducing informality: return migration from social housing as constrained agency in climate-driven relocation in coastal Jakarta
Аннотация
In coastal cities, informal settlers experience the highest exposure to flooding under climate change, and local authorities use planned relocation as an adaptation strategy to support flood-mitigation measures. Post-relocation, many families return to informal settlements instead of settling in formal vertical social housing (rusunawa). This paper examines the pattern and drivers of return migration from rusunawa to informal settlements (kampung) in coastal Jakarta and how return reproduces informality. Using a sequential explanatory mixed-methods design, the study combines quantitative data from household surveys of families relocated to Rusunawa Marunda and Rusunawa Muara Baru, conducted in 2015 and 2017, with qualitative data in the same neighborhoods in 2025. We conducted in-depth interviews with 53 informants, including 35 returned households who were relocated and surveyed in 2015 and 2017. Findings show that return migration peaked between six and twelve months after relocation, coinciding with the expiry of rent subsidies. The move from informal to formal housing produces four difficulties: loss of income sources, rigid housing arrangements, disrupted community ties, and exclusion from decision-making. Return restores livelihoods and social support, yet it is a constrained form of agency that leaves households with insecure tenure and flood exposure. Relocation should be designed for livelihood continuity and participatory governance, not displacement alone.