Trade-offs among ecosystem services under agricultural diversification practices. A meta-analysis
Аннотация
Agricultural diversification practices are widely used as a pathway to sustainable crop yield, yet integrated and multidimensional assessments of their trade-offs among ecosystem services remain limited. To investigate these trade-offs, we synthesized 78 published meta-analyses with a reported sample size of 54,426 to evaluate the effect of agroforestry, cover crops, cultivar mixture, crop rotation, and intercropping across biodiversity, carbon sequestration, climate-forcing proxies, soil functioning, water regulation, crop yield, and pest, disease, and weed suppression. Overall, agricultural diversification practices improved biodiversity by 35.08%, carbon sequestration by 22.57%, and soil functioning by 29.24% but reduced water regulation (−17.00%) and pest, disease, and weed suppression (−27.75%), while effects on crop yield and climate-forcing proxies remained highly dependent on context. Crop rotation and intercropping showed relatively broad benefits for soil functioning and carbon sequestration, whereas cover crops were more consistently associated with soil and carbon gains; agroforestry and cultivar mixture were more variable. Pairings among biodiversity, carbon sequestration, and soil functioning occurred mainly in the win-win quadrant, whereas pairings involving water regulation or pest, disease, and weed suppression more often indicated trade-offs or lose-lose outcomes. Among the five highest scoring Pareto profiles, biodiversity, carbon sequestration, and soil functioning generally showed positive responses, whereas climate-forcing proxies, water regulation, and pest, disease, and weed suppression varied. Thus, agricultural diversification produces selective, context-dependent benefits, and the optimized profiles should be interpreted as hypotheses about compatible service priorities rather than implementable management. Our study is the first to introduce a multi-objective optimization framework into a second-order meta-analysis to assess the comprehensive impact of agricultural diversification on ecosystem services, extending conventional pairwise assessments and providing an exploratory framework for optimization.