Do You Ever Get Tired of Being Wrong? The Unique Impact of Feedback on Subjective Experiences of Effort
Аннотация
Two of the biggest obstacles to persisting with a task are the need to overcome fatigue and the need to overcome failure. These two experiences are thought to arise from separate monitoring systems – one focused on monitoring one’s effort exertion, the other focused on monitoring one’s performance (e.g., based on external feedback and internal confidence signals). Here, we ask whether these systems might be more intertwined than previously thought, and in particular whether it is possible for negative feedback to directly impact (and exacerbate) one’s experience of fatigue on a task. To address this question, we had 68 participants perform a task in which their goal was to squeeze a handgrip to within a target force level. On most trials, they were given no feedback on whether they met their goal and were largely unable to detect how they had performed. On a subset of trials, however, we provided participants with (false) feedback indicating that they had either succeeded or failed at meeting their goal (positive vs. negative feedback blocks, respectively). Participants sporadically rated their experience of effort exertion, fatigue, and confidence in having met the goal on that trial. Despite being non-veridical to their actual performance, the type of feedback participants received influenced their effort experience. When receiving negative (vs. positive) feedback, participants fatigued faster and adjusted their grip strength more for higher target force levels. Confidence also increased with increasing positive feedback and decreased with increasing negative feedback, again despite feedback being uniformly uninformative. These results suggest differential influences of feedback on effort-related experiences and shed additional light on the relationship between performance monitoring and effort monitoring.