Unconscious thought in complex decisions: Which decision-making strategies do people use?

Lei, Chao, Gregory, Lance, Tao, Huan, Pan, Jingjing
Journal of Marketing Analytics · Springer Nature · 2026-10-31 · DOI: 10.1057/s41270-026-00559-y

Аннотация

An optimal decision depends not only on product information but also on the mode of thought individuals engage in. While previous studies have examined the advantages of unconscious thought over conscious thought, findings remain mixed regarding which mode leads to superior outcomes in complex choice tasks. Furthermore, it remains unclear which decision-making strategies individuals engaged in unconscious thought may use. Therefore, this research investigates which mode facilitates optimal decision-making in complex choice tasks and which strategies are associated with unconscious and conscious thought. Across five studies, we find that unconscious thought can facilitate superior decision outcomes compared with conscious thought. Our findings further provide evidence consistent with greater reliance on a compensatory weighting strategy among individuals engaged in unconscious thought. We also find that time pressure may alter this pattern, with evidence suggesting greater reliance on a noncompensatory lexicographic strategy under time pressure. Our work contributes to the literature on unconscious thought by providing further evidence regarding its benefits in complex choice, offering insight into the decision strategy associated with unconscious thought, and identifying time pressure as a potential boundary condition. These findings also provide implications for online retailers seeking to structure product information and decision environments that support consumer decision-making.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи