Medical Science Educator Education

“Playing the Game”: A Phenomenological Exploration of Trainee Experiences with a Rank-Based Residency Selection Matching Process

Preti, Beatrice T. B., Mangel, Joy, Wang, Peter, Stein, Robert, Sanatani, Michael S.
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s40670-026-02934-x

Abstract

Introduction Postgraduate medical education positions in Canada are determined through a residency match selection process. The process was developed to provide an organised, equitable, learner-centric way to balance the interests of programs and applicants. However, previous feedback from learners in several match systems has highlighted inherent moral and professional tensions. A deep understanding of how learners experience the navigation of such tensions, and the match in general, could focus future research and educational quality improvement around those areas most relevant to preparing medical students for the match process. Method Six individuals who had taken part in the Canadian residency participated in semi-structured interviews, which were then recorded, transcribed, and analysed according to Van Manen’s hermeneutic phenomenological approach. Essential individual themes were combined into core experiential categories and composite narrative constructed. Results Core experiential themes were (1) feeling that residency matching processes is flawed and lacks transparency; (2) perceiving that to be successful one needs to play the “game”; (3) struggling to convey to programs what trainees feel matters; (4) perceiving inconsistency in support availability and efficacy; and (5) possessing awareness that implications of residency matching processes are life-changing. Conclusions The reported elements of trainee experience suggest that the high stakes of the match process and perceived lack of transparency play core shaping roles here. Research clarifying what really matters to selection committees, and provision of opportunities in medical curricula for broader career wayfinding outside a context where impression management overshadows authentic exploration, may impact this experience positively in the future.

Read at publisher →