Digital War Humanities and social sciences

The authority gap: why meaningful human control fails at the tier where it is signed

Oktenli, Burak
Springer Nature · 2026-08-31 · DOI 10.1057/s42984-026-00113-1

Abstract

As autonomous functions migrate into the targeting cycle, the doctrine of meaningful human control has anchored the debate over autonomous weapons. A rich critical literature has shown, empirically and discursively, that the control humans exercise over such systems is often closer to meaningless than meaningful. This article asks why. It argues that the hollowness the literature documents has an identifiable architectural source. Authority in contemporary military decision systems is distributed across computational tiers, and the human signature attaches at a terminal tier downstream of the tiers where classification, proportionality and collateral-damage estimation are computed. The result is the terminal-systemic authority gap: control is formally present yet substantively hollow, because the endorser cannot review machine-paced, opaque reasoning within the decision window. Situating this account within recent scholarship on meaningful human control, and distinguishing military decision systems from civilian algorithmic systems by their development context, legal framework and deployment practice, the article reframes control as a property of the authority architecture governed across the technology’s full life cycle, and draws implications for design, oversight and accountability without assuming that design alone can carry the burden.

Read at publisher →