From Impact to Regeneration: Healing the Separation in Financial Thought
Аннотация
This paper critiques the dominant framework of modern financial theory and presents impact investing and regenerative finance as morally grounded alternatives. Impact investing expands the utility function of investors to include non-financial outcomes but still operates within a logic of constrained optimization and trade-offs. Regenerative finance goes further by seeking to re-integrate finance into the web of social, ecological, and spiritual relationships that sustain human flourishing. Drawing on Catholic Social Teaching, Fullerton’s (2025) principles of regenerative vitality, and recent governance innovations, this paper articulates a framework for finance as a moral vocation rather than a technical discipline. A central contribution of this paper is a typology of abundance—material, existential, and performative—which contrasts with the scarcity logic underpinning modern financial theory. The paper critiques foundational reductionist assumptions, especially those formalized by Fisher (1930) and Robbins (1932), that treat human persons as utility maximizers and exclude subjective goods from financial models. Through real-world case studies and engagement with philosophical perspectives, this paper illustrates both the promise and limits of regenerative finance. By going beyond systems design, this paper offers a metaphysical foundation for why regeneration is necessary and what it might look like in finance.