Financial Benefits Assessment of Napier Grass under Monocropping and Intercropping with Foundation Plants
Abstract
The financial potential of Napier grass ( Pennisetum purpureum ) as a feedstock for biogas-based electricity generation was evaluated by integrating field-derived biomass-yield and specific methane-yield datasets with a farmer-level economic analysis in a tropical coastal region of southern Thailand. Four species—Dwarf, Pak Chong 1, Bana, and Suvarnabhumi (a newly developed Thai species)—were cultivated under two fertilization treatments and three harvest intervals (60, 90, and 120 days). The system was assessed for sustaining a 1 MW biogas power plant, incorporating transportation distances of 10–30 km and key financial indicators, including Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), and Payback Period (PBP). The results showed that SV-F52-C60 required the smallest cultivation area (134 ± 34 ha) and was retained as the integrated system-level recommendation, whereas PC-F52-C90 achieved the highest farmer-level financial return. Under the high biomass-price scenario of $42.86/t and a transportation distance of 10 km, SV-F52-C60 generated a net profit of $3,748/ha/year, with an NPV of $21,526/ha, an IRR of 241.7%, and a PBP of 0.44 years. Fertilization enhanced economic performance by increasing biomass yield, thereby increasing NPV and IRR while shortening PBP. Increasing transportation distance reduced the modeled economic returns, although the selected high-yield cases remained profitable at 30 km. Beyond monocropping, scenario-based economic projections suggested that pineapple–Napier grass rotation could increase annual profit by 9.4–10.5%, while coconut–Napier grass intercropping could increase annual profit by 195.5–199.6%. These findings identify SV-F52-C60 as a financially competitive option requiring the smallest cultivation area for biogas feedstock production under the site-specific conditions evaluated.