Exploring Plant Consciousness: A Critical Review of Cellular Basis, Local, and Non-Local Theories

Entomological Review · Springer Nature · 2026-10-23 · DOI: 10.1007/s12304-026-09670-0

Аннотация

Consciousness remains one of the most elusive and debated concepts in science, particularly regarding its possible existence in non-human organisms such as plants. Much of the controversy stems from different conceptions of the nature and basis of consciousness. In this review, we distinguish among three approaches: the Cellular Basis of Consciousness (CBC), which proposes that consciousness is rooted in the properties and processes of living cells; local (brain-dependent) theories, which regard consciousness as an emergent property of neural activity; and non-local (brain-independent) theories, which consider consciousness a fundamental property of reality that exists independently of the brain and physical body. The debate over plant consciousness reflects these contrasting assumptions. Proponents argue that plants exhibit sophisticated behaviors, information processing, adaptive responses, learning, memory, and neural-like signaling mechanisms that may indicate a form of consciousness despite the absence of a brain. Opponents argue that consciousness requires neural structures capable of supporting subjective experience. By comparing these competing perspectives, this review provides an integrative conceptual framework for interpreting current evidence and evaluating the assumptions underlying different theories of plant consciousness. We argue that resolving this controversy will require an integrative approach that draws on insights from biology, neuroscience, philosophy of mind, complexity science, and related disciplines. Ultimately, the debate over plant consciousness reflects more fundamental questions in consciousness research: Is consciousness a product of life, or does life emerge from consciousness? Are consciousness and life distinct phenomena, or are they coterminous?

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи