Conservation Genetics Генетика
Do SNPs change conservation inference? comparing genomic and microsatellite markers for brook trout in the southern appalachians
Аннотация
Understanding patterns of genetic diversity and population structure is essential for conserving species in fragmented and declining habitats. Molecular markers such as microsatellites and single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are widely used to inform management of diverse wildlife populations, but their relative strengths and limitations across different population contexts are not well understood for many systems. We compared microsatellite and SNP datasets for 39 wild brook trout ( Salvelinus fontinalis ) populations from 12 watersheds in western North Carolina to evaluate how marker choice affects inferences about within-population diversity, population differentiation, and hierarchical structure. Principal component analysis and discriminant analysis of principal components revealed broadly concordant patterns between marker types. Observed heterozygosity and pairwise F _ST values were strongly correlated between microsatellites and SNPs, indicating broad consistency with respect to patterns of diversity within and among populations. Furthermore, fine-scale analyses in two adjacent watersheds yielded broadly consistent patterns across marker types, suggesting that either marker system would likely support similar management decisions in conservation applications such as reintroductions and donor site selection. Overall, our study suggests that, when exploring population-level demographic relationships, both microsatellites and SNPs are capable of generating robust insights for many populations and conservation questions. Which marker to employ ultimately depends on the specific research objectives, where SNPs offer higher resolution and unique insights into adaptive relationships, and microsatellites provide greater efficiency with small sample sizes and remain applicable when legacy datasets are available.