Biology & Philosophy Гуманитарные и социальные науки
Unexpected patterns, irrelevance, and scientific explanation
Аннотация
Contrary to most accounts of explanation that have focused on difference-making, several philosophers have recently proposed that information about irrelevant features can contribute to scientific explanations. Two key questions arise for this approach: (1) what does the irrelevance of these features uniquely contribute to scientific explanations—beyond the contributions of difference makers—and (2) which irrelevant features ought to be cited in an explanation. In this paper, I argue that what irrelevance information uniquely contributes is the ability to explain the unexpected stability of patterns across contexts in which different difference-makers are responsible for the explanandum. These cases also show that scientists’ expectations and current best theories play a crucial role in determining which irrelevance information ought to be included and which can be left implicit.